Advocates bulking up for the next battle with Big Soda

printer friendlyprinter friendly

In the aftermath of two failed measures that would have taxed sugar-sweetened beverages at a penny-per-ounce, the beverage industry has been flexing its muscles and kicking sand in the faces of soda tax proponents.

Just like those old comic book ads in which a scrawny man and his girlfriend are lounging by the seashore when a big muscular guy comes over to bully them, Big Beverage poured $3.7 million to defeat soda tax measures in Richmond and El Monte in southern California. In Richmond alone, the beverage industry outspent supporters by 35 to 1. In all, Big Soda spent $115 per vote.

But, just like the ad for famed bodybuilder Charles Atlas' muscle-building program, being pushed around on the beach only motivated scrawny guy to bulk up so he could come back and defeat muscle man once and for all.

It's that bodybuilder-scrawny man dynamic that pushed Richmond resident Jenny Wang over the edge.

"The thing that affected me most was that here we were a small grassroots group fighting multi-billion dollar corporations," said Wang. "That stark contrast made me more passionate. I developed such a disdain for these large corporations essentially buying this election."

Wang, a public health professional who works in Oakland, became interested in the Richmond tax proposal after hearing about it from fellow residents.

"I was already convinced taxing sugar-sweetened beverages was a good idea, but I was just confused about (Measure N) and where the money would go. After I learned that it would be used to support programs aimed at fighting the obesity epidemic that soda has been such a major cause of, I was immediately on board," recalled Wang.

Richmond's Measure O, which passed but was made moot by the defeat of its companion Measure N, would have advised the city to use the tax proceeds, estimated to be around $3 million annually, on after-school activity programs, parks, diabetes education and other programs to fight childhood obesity. A measure in El Monte in southern California that was similar to Measure N lost 77 to 23.

"We lost the election, but the movement will eventually win," Dr. Jeff Ritterman told the San Francisco Chronicle. Ritterman is the Richmond city councilman who sponsored the tax proposal.

The newspaper quoted Berkeley City Councilwoman Linda Maio as saying: "Are we daunted by what happened in Richmond? Not at all. Not one bit."

Others were also quoted, including a Half Moon Bay resident who, inspired by Richmond, is lobbying San Mateo County officials to move ahead with a soda tax.

Ritterman has announced a new goal to see 14 California cities put forth soda tax proposals by 2014, with the idea that this flurry of measures would stretch the beverage industry's resources so thin that this might allow a few of the ballot proposals to pass.

For Wang, the fight against Big Soda is personal.

"I come from a low-income family of savers and coupon clippers. I can't get my family to not buy soda when it's on sale. When you can buy a 2-liter bottle of soda for 99 cents, or get a 12-pack of soda free when you buy the first pack, you're going to buy the soda over the bottled water," said Wang. "I have aunts and uncles with diabetes. It's hurting my family. It's hurting me."

Although Ritterman and soda tax supporters like Wang were understandably disappointed by the losses, they are bolstered by the lessons learned in the soda tax campaigns -- not least that money buys votes, as noted nutrition and public policy expert Marion Nestle pointed out in a recent San Francisco Chronicle editorial.

"But it also taught (us) that appeals to voter concerns about higher prices, job losses and personal autonomy are more effective than appeals based solely on health considerations," Nestle told the Chronicle.

Wang agreed, and has taken such lessons to heart for the next go-round.

"We framed the health message. (Big Soda) framed the cost message, saying that it would hike up the cost of buying groceries and hit low-income people the hardest. We should borrow that frame," said Wang. "The health costs of obesity is coming out of your pocket. That's the bottom line."


soda warning labels (1) Joe Paterno (1) filibuster (1) Merck (1) gun control (2) sexual assault (1) soda (12) sexism (2) front groups (1) naacp (1) American Beverage Association (1) personal responsibility rhetoric (1) children's health (3) beauty products (1) Donald Trump (2) El Monte (3) collaboration (1) framing (14) Berkeley (2) news analysis (3) Telluride (1) Texas (1) stigma (1) diabetes prevention (1) cervical cancer (1) autism (1) world water day (1) cap the tap (1) Wendy Davis (1) Rachel Grana (1) Black Lives Matter (1) food deserts (1) seat belt laws (1) corporate social responsibility (1) Tea Party (1) soda taxes (2) suicide nets (1) vaccines (1) childhood lead poisoning (1) obesity (10) sexual violence (2) Aurora (1) violence (2) Whiteclay (4) media advocacy (21) Catholic church (1) snap (1) measure N (2) water (1) paper tigers (1) target marketing (7) Bloomberg (3) prison phone calls (1) physical activity (1) Food Marketing Workgroup (1) food industry (4) language (6) women's health (2) Proposition 29 (1) community (1) messaging (3) cigarette advertising (1) social change (1) digital marketing (2) news strategy (1) Gardasil (1) suicide barrier (2) Big Food (2) ssb (1) Citizens United (1) news (2) social justice (1) childhood adversity (1) race (1) adverse childhood experiences (3) water security (1) inequities (1) Nickelodeon (1) Penn State (3) marketing (1) Newtown (1) george lakoff (1) environmental health (1) Oglala Sioux (3) beverage industry (2) journalism (1) equity (3) sugary drinks (10) food marketing (3) Pine Ridge reservation (1) new year's resolutions (1) food swamps (1) choice (1) soda industry (4) food environment (1) social media (2) Marion Nestle (1) San Francisco (3) values (1) childhood obestiy conference (1) suicide prevention (2) political correctness (1) violence prevention (8) media (7) Golden Gate Bridge (2) healthy eating (1) Sandy Hook (2) education (1) food and beverage marketing (3) nanny state (2) food (1) Dora the Explorer (1) Connecticut shooting (1) ACEs (2) built environment (2) industry appeals to choice (1) FCC (1) genital warts (1) Bill Cosby (1) default frame (1) news monitoring (1) apha (2) media analysis (5) prison system (1) weight of the nation (1) tobacco tax (1) Measure O (1) soda tax (11) health equity (10) childhood obesity (1) chronic disease (2) Campaign for Safe Cosmetics (1) gender (1) Coca-Cola (3) safety (1) reproductive justice (1) gun violence (1) Twitter (1) Colorado (1) obesity prevention (1) sports drinks (1) cosmetics (1) Johnson & Johnson (1) paula deen (1) junk food (2) election 2016 (1) SSBs (1) sugar-sweetened beverages (2) prevention (1) online marketing (1) community organizing (1) community violence (1) campaign finance (1) childhood trauma (3) communication (2) advocacy (3) Happy Meals (1) Jerry Sandusky (3) white house (1) government intrusion (1) social math (1) product safety (1) indoor smoking ban (1) gatorade bolt game (1) Twitter for advocacy (1) SB 1000 (1) tobacco industry (2) health care (1) sandusky (2) authentic voices (1) emergency contraception (1) elephant triggers (1) regulation (2) Amanda Fallin (1) Proposition 47 (1) privilege (1) Big Tobacco (3) public health data (1) Sam Kass (1) summer camps (1) liana winett (1) McDonald's (1) sexual health (1) HPV vaccine (1) california (1) public health (67) cancer prevention (1) Let's Move (1) tobacco (5) auto safety (1) Chile (1) Pine Ridge Indian Reservation (2) food justice (1) PepsiCo (1) breastfeeding (3) junk food marketing (3) democracy (1) media bites (1) Big Soda (2) personal responsibility (3) youth (1) institutional accountability (1) cancer research (1) structural racism (1) SB 402 (1) diabetes (1) Community Coalition Against Beverage Taxes (1) tobacco control (2) racism (1) Oakland Unified School District (1) Richmond (5) alcohol (5) sanitation (1) food access (1) child sexual abuse (5) public health policy (2) news coverage (1) junk food marketing to kids (2) abortion (1) SB-5 (1) mental health (2) Michelle Obama (1) community safety (1) community health (1)
  • Follow Us On Facebook
  • Follow Us On Twitter
  • Join Us On Youtube
  • BMSG RSS Feed

get e-alerts in your inbox: